Oscars are rare and highly collectible, occupying a unique space in the world of movie memorabilia. The Academy’s rules have created a bifurcated black market for stoeln Oscars, with pre-1950 Oscars being highly prized and post-1950 Oscars rarely available.
The combination of rarity, historical significance, and iconic status makes Oscars a fascinating and valuable collectible for those fortunate enough to own one. For collectors, an Oscar represents not just a trophy but a tangible piece of Hollywood’s storied past. For thieves, they have created an opportunity, albeit a risky one, selling Oscars on the black market.
The story of the Oscars continues after this advertisement:
Are Oscars Collectible? The Intriguing World of Academy Award Memorabilia
The allure of the Academy Awards, commonly known as the Oscars, extends far beyond the glitz and glamour of Hollywood’s biggest night. These iconic statuettes, awarded since 1929, symbolize the pinnacle of cinematic achievement.
But are Oscars collectible? The answer is a resounding yes, but the world of Oscar collecting is shrouded in unique rules, high stakes, and a rich history that makes it unlike any other memorabilia market.
The Golden Statuette: A Coveted Prize
Oscars are not only prestigious but also rare, with only a limited number awarded each year. Their scarcity, combined with their iconic status, makes them highly coveted by collectors.
When the Academy began handing them out in 1928 they were cast in bronze, with 24-karat gold plating. During World War II the statuettes were made of plaster because of metal shortages. Today, the 8½-pound statuettes are made of gold-plated britannium, a metal alloy that doesn’t have a lot of value, per se.
The 24-karat gold-plated statuette, designed by Cedric Gibbons and sculpted by George Stanley, is instantly recognizable and carries immense sentimental and financial value.
Standing 13.25 inches tall, measuring 10.25 inches high and 3.5 inches wide, the statuettes are cast in a pewter-like alloy known as “Britannia metal,” then plated with layers of copper, nickel silver, and finally, 24-karat gold.
The statue rests on a bevelled black base, 3 inches high and 5 inches round at the bottom, tapering to 4.5 inches where it attaches to the film reel that forms the statue’s foot. A brass plaque, measuring 6 by 1 inches and curved to fit the base, is engraved with the inscription which names the winner, what it was for, the movie’s name and the year.
The original mold for the Oscar was cast in 1928 at the C.W. Shumway & Sons Foundry in Batavia, Illinois. Since 1983, R.S. Owens & Company in Chicago has fabricated the Oscars annually.
Notable Sales and Auctions
Several high-profile sales have highlighted the collectible nature of Oscars:
Clark Gable’s Oscar: The Best Actor Oscar won by Clark Gable for “It Happened One Night” (1934) sold for $607,500 at auction in 1996.
Bette Davis’s Oscar: Bette Davis’s Best Actress Oscar for “Jezebel” (1938) was sold for $207,500 in 2001.
Michael Jackson’s Purchase: Pop icon Michael Jackson purchased the Best Picture Oscar for “Gone with the Wind” (1939) for a record-breaking $1.54 million in 1999. Pictured: Producer David O. Selznick’s 1939 Best Picture Oscar for Gone with the Wind. The Oscar has since gone missing from his estate and its whereabouts is unknown.
Citizen Kane Oscar: The only Oscar awarded for “Citizen Kane” (1941) was auctioned for nearly $900,000 in 2011. Citizen Kane’s Oscar sold for $645,000.00 via Heritage Auctions in 2024.
These sales underscore the high demand and significant market for Oscars among collectors.
Legal Measures to Prevent the Sale of Oscars
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences (AMPAS) has stringent rules regarding the sale and ownership of Oscars and taken legal measures to prevent the sale of Oscar statuettes.
Since 1950, the Academy has required all Oscar recipients to sign a legal agreement known as the “winner’s agreement.” This agreement stipulates that neither the recipients nor their heirs can sell or otherwise dispose of the Oscar statuette without first offering it back to the Academy for the nominal sum of $1.
This rule was made to prevent the commercial exploitation of the awards, preserving the prestige of winning an Oscar, and ensuring that they remain symbols of artistic achievement rather than commercial commodities.
As a result, Oscars awarded after 1950 rarely appear on the open market. Oscars awarded before 1950 are not subject to the Academy’s buyback rule, making them highly sought after by collectors. These early Oscars occasionally come up for auction, fetching impressive sums.
The Black Market and Unauthorized Sales
Despite the Academy’s efforts, a black market for Oscars exists. Some Oscars have been stolen and sold illicitly, leading to legal battles and high-profile recoveries.
The strict rules and high value of these awards have created a niche but fervent market, where collectors are willing to pay top dollar for a piece of cinematic history.
To ensure compliance with the winner’s agreement, the Academy monitors auctions and private sales, taking legal action when necessary. They have established a clear stance that Oscar statuettes are not commercial items but rather symbols of artistic excellence that should remain within the Academy’s purview.
Legal Precedents and Court Orders
The Academy has actively enforced this agreement through legal action, including court orders, to prevent the sale of Oscars. Here are some notable instances:
Michael Todd’s Oscar: In 1993, the Academy successfully obtained a court order to block the sale of producer Michael Todd’s Best Picture Oscar for “Around the World in 80 Days” (1956). The Academy argued that the sale violated the winner’s agreement, and the court ruled in their favor, preventing the auction from proceeding.
Orson Welles’s Oscar: In 2003, the Academy intervened in the sale of Orson Welles’s Best Original Screenplay Oscar for “Citizen Kane” (1941). Welles had never signed the winner’s agreement, as his Oscar predated the rule. Despite this, the Academy attempted to stop the sale but ultimately lost the legal battle, and the Oscar was auctioned off in 2011 for nearly $900,000.
Vivien Leigh’s Oscars: In 1993, the Academy also intervened to prevent the sale of Vivien Leigh’s Best Actress Oscars for “Gone with the Wind” (1939) and “A Streetcar Named Desire” (1951). After a legal battle, the Academy managed to halt the sale, citing the winner’s agreement.
The Curious Case of Stolen Oscars: Hollywood’s Missing Icons
The Oscars, synonymous with cinematic excellence, represent the zenith of achievement in the film industry. These golden statuettes are highly coveted by filmmakers and cherished by fans worldwide.
However, the allure of these prestigious awards has occasionally led to their theft, creating intriguing tales of mystery and recovery. Here are some of the most notable cases of stolen Oscars.
The Great Oscar Heist of 2000
One of the most infamous Oscar thefts occurred just before the 2000 Academy Awards. A shipment of 55 Oscar statuettes, en route from the manufacturer R.S. Owens in Chicago to Los Angeles, mysteriously disappeared.
Panic ensued within the Academy as the awards ceremony loomed without its prized trophies. The story took a dramatic turn when a scrap metal worker named Willie Fulgear discovered 52 of the missing Oscars in a dumpster behind a supermarket in Koreatown, Los Angeles.
Fulgear’s find made headlines, and he was rewarded with $50,000 and tickets to the Oscars.
Whoopi Goldberg’s Missing Oscar
In 2002, Whoopi Goldberg’s Oscar for her role in “Ghost” (1990) vanished during a trip from California to Chicago, where it was being cleaned and re-plated.
When the Academy received an empty box instead of the statuette, an investigation was launched. Remarkably, the Oscar was found weeks later in a trash can at Ontario Airport in California, returned by an anonymous individual.
The case remains unsolved, but Goldberg was reunited with her treasured award.
Margaret O’Brien’s Lost and Found Oscar
Margaret O’Brien, a child star of the 1940s, received a special juvenile Oscar in 1945. In 1954, the award was stolen from her home. Decades later, in 1995, a couple discovered the Oscar at a Pasadena flea market and purchased it for a mere $500.
After confirming its authenticity, the Academy presented O’Brien with a replacement statuette. However, the original award was eventually returned to O’Brien in 1995, thanks to the couple’s diligence and a bit of serendipity.
Hattie McDaniel’s Vanished Oscar
Hattie McDaniel made history in 1940 by becoming the first African American to win an Academy Award for her role in “Gone with the Wind.” Her Oscar, a plaque rather than the traditional statuette, was bequeathed to Howard University upon her death in 1952.
Unfortunately, the award went missing during the Civil Rights era in the 1960s and has never been recovered. Despite numerous efforts to locate the plaque, it remains one of Hollywood’s enduring mysteries.
Bing Crosby’s Stolen and Recovered Oscar
Bing Crosby won the Best Actor Oscar for his performance in “Going My Way” (1944). In the 1960s, Crosby’s Oscar was stolen from his home. It resurfaced in 1996 when a woman attempted to sell it at an auction.
Authorities intervened, and the Oscar was returned to Crosby’s estate. This incident highlighted the black market for stolen Hollywood memorabilia and the lengths to which thieves would go to profit from these iconic awards.
The Oscar Theft That Inspired a Movie
In 2005, two-time Oscar winner Hillary Swank’s Academy Award for “Boys Don’t Cry” (1999) was stolen from her home. The incident served as a plot point for the 2006 film “Freedom Writers,” in which Swank starred.
Fortunately, the award was recovered by Los Angeles police within a week, underscoring the high-profile nature of such thefts and the rapid response by law enforcement.
The theft of Oscars is a rare but fascinating phenomenon that underscores the immense value placed on these awards. Each stolen Oscar comes with its own story, blending Hollywood glamour with elements of mystery and intrigue.
While some stolen Oscars have been miraculously recovered, others remain lost, adding to the allure and legend of these golden statuettes. The tales of stolen Oscars remind us that even the most glittering symbols of success can sometimes vanish into thin air, only to reappear in the most unexpected ways.
Citizen Kane’s Oscar sold in 2024
The Oscar statuette, awarded to Orson Welles and Herman J. Mankiewicz for Best Original Screenplay, for the 1941 masterpiece “Citizen Kane,” sold for $645,000.00 via Heritage Auctions on 28 July 2024.
Orson Welles, with his debut film “Citizen Kane,” ascended to the zenith of cinematic artistry. Welles not only directed but also produced, co-wrote, and starred in the film, which has been celebrated as one of the greatest films of all time.
The screenplay, co-written with esteemed screenwriter Herman J. Mankiewicz, is renowned for its innovative narrative structure. “Citizen Kane” has influenced a host of legendary directors, including John Huston, Akira Kurosawa, Stanley Kubrick, MiloÅ¡ Forman, and Martin Scorsese, solidifying its status as a timeless artistic achievement.
The Oscar statuette itself is a piece of art, sculpted by George Stanley, who also created the famous “Muse Fountain” at the Hollywood Bowl.
This particular statuette was a replacement requested by Welles after he misplaced the original award. Despite minor wear and tear, including rubbing, loss of plating, and scratches, the statuette remains a stunning and recognizable emblem of cinematic history.
This Oscar, one of the few ever made available to the public, is not only a rare collectible but also a tribute to one of the greatest films ever made. Its significance as a top award for “Citizen Kane” underscores the film’s lasting influence and the artistic possibilities it continues to inspire in the world of cinema.
Related stories
Top 10 Rare Valuable and Collectible Vinyl Records
Should Kevin Spacey Remain Cancelled?
See our Collectibles Feature Stories for more
The Top 20 rarest and most valuable U.S. coins
The story of the NSW Rum Corp, Holey Dollar and Dump coins
Luxurious Elegance: Hermés Handbags
Guide to Collecting Vintage Film Cameras
