Prince Philip and the Rumour Mill: Fact, Fiction, and the Women History Can’t Forget
When a man spends seventy years as the Queen’s consort, rumour inevitably becomes his shadow. For Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, the whispers began early, intensified through the 1950s, and never quite died down — even though proof never materialised.
Both of Prince Philip’s sons inherited their share of tabloid scrutiny — and then some. Prince Charles’s long-running affair with Camilla Parker Bowles, now Queen Camilla, was perhaps the most public royal scandal of the late 20th century, exposed through leaked phone calls and culminating in the disintegration of his marriage to Princess Diana.
Andrew’s (formerly known as prince) reputation, meanwhile, imploded over his friendship with Jeffrey Epstein and allegations of sexual misconduct — claims he has denied but which led to his royal titles and patronages being stripped.
Together, their controversies chart the evolution of royal scandal itself: from whispered infidelity to full-blown global headlines in the age of the internet.
Charles and Andrew chip off the old block
Prince Philip once dismissed rumours of extra-marital affairs with a grin: “Have you ever stopped to think that for the last 40 years I’ve never moved anywhere without a policeman accompanying me? So how the hell could I get away with anything like that?”
The story of Philip’s so-called “affairs” says less about the man and more about the machinery of monarchy, media, and myth.
Advertisement:
A Royal Marriage in the Spotlight
Philip and Elizabeth married in 1947 — young, glamorous, and photogenic, the original postwar influencers before Instagram was a gleam in Silicon Valley’s eye. But glamour carries a curse: the public demands perfection, and the tabloids demand cracks.
By 1956, those cracks were headline material. The Duke embarked on a solo five-month world tour aboard HMY Britannia, while back home, his close friend and private secretary Michael Parker’s marriage imploded. The Parker divorce was juicy, scandalous, and, by association, royal. Soon whispers spread that Philip’s long voyage wasn’t purely diplomatic.
Buckingham Palace responded with characteristic frost: denial, followed by silence. Philip returned to the Queen’s side, and life — or at least royal duty — went on.
Women Caught in the Crossfire
The Duke’s circle included actors, aristocrats, and socialites. Most were long-term friends; all became tabloid fodder.
Pat Kirkwood, a British stage and screen star, suffered the worst of it. After one dinner and a dance with Philip in 1948, Fleet Street married them off in print. Kirkwood, whose only sin was being seen in his company, spent decades denying any affair. “A lady is not normally expected to defend her honour,” she said, “but I shall do so until my last breath.”
Hélène Cordet, a French-born singer and TV host, faced speculation after Philip became godfather to her two sons. The press leapt to conclusions; Cordet and Philip maintained a lifelong friendship, but nothing more.
Then there was Sacha Hamilton, Duchess of Abercorn, who described their bond as “a passionate friendship” — and clarified immediately that passion didn’t mean sex. “It was an intellectual passion,” she said. “The idea of an affair is ridiculous.”
More recently, Penelope Knatchbull, Countess Mountbatten of Burma, found herself written into gossip columns and Netflix scripts alike. She and Philip shared carriage-driving and mutual solace after personal losses. Friends called it companionship. The tabloids, inevitably, called it something else.
Prince Philip’s name was also linked to Susan Barrantes, mother of Sarah, Duchess of York, and to Penelope Brabourne, Countess Mountbatten of Burma — both long-time family friends. British tabloids speculated about those friendships for years, though neither woman nor the Duke ever confirmed any romantic involvement. The Palace never commented, adhering to its standard policy of silence on personal rumours.
These stories, repeated by outlets from Mamamia to The Telegraph, illustrate how gossip about Philip’s friendships endured across decades — not through evidence, but through fascination with a man who remained as private as he was public.
The Crown Effect
Netflix’s The Crown threw new oxygen on decades-old speculation. Creative license blurred into memory; characters became composite figures; subtext became subplot.
Historians note that the real Philip bristled at portrayals suggesting marital infidelity. “The Duke of Edinburgh is not amused,” was how palace sources reportedly put it. But as every dramatist knows, ambiguity sells better than certainty.
The Making of a Myth
Why did the rumours stick?
Because a royal mystery is irresistible. Because the British press in the 1950s operated under the twin gods of discretion and innuendo. Because a handsome prince with a military bearing and a quick wit was tabloid gold.
And perhaps because Philip — outspoken, modernising, and occasionally tactless — didn’t play the deferential consort. His independence made him interesting, and the monarchy has always been uneasy with interesting men.
Advertisement:
Rumours vs. Records
| Year | Event | Media Reaction |
|---|---|---|
| 1948 | Dinner and theatre with Pat Kirkwood | “Rendezvous with a Prince” headlines; Kirkwood denies affair |
| 1956–57 | Britannia tour; Parker divorce | Speculation about marital rift; Palace denial |
| 1960s | Friendship with Hélène Cordet | Paternity rumours dismissed |
| 1970s | Friendship with Duchess of Abercorn | Duchess clarifies “passionate friendship” |
| 1990s–2000s | Carriage driving with Penny Knatchbull | “Confidante” headlines; no evidence of affair |
Legacy of a Lifetime
In the end, the Duke’s reputation weathered decades of gossip. What remains is a record of unwavering public duty — 22,000 solo engagements, 5,000 speeches, and 70 years beside a monarch.
He was witty, restless, and occasionally brusque, but by all verifiable accounts, devoted to his wife. The rumours, like much of royal folklore, are part of Britain’s cultural wallpaper: endlessly repeated, never proved.
The only affair Philip could be convicted of, it seems, was with adventure itself.
Related stories
How I shot the Queen ° CHOGM 2002 Official Queen’s Portrait
King Charles III and the new Great Seal of Australia
1990 Auckland Commonwealth Games Opening Ceremony
Stuff the British Stole: Antiquities and Repatriation
Colonel Blood’s plot to pinch the British Crown Jewels
The Charge of the Light Brigade poems by Tennyson & Kipling
Gough Whitlam & Malcolm Turnbull at the SpyCatcher Trial
How The Australia Institute Helped Build the NACC
The French Crown Jewels stolen from the Louvre, Paris
It’s time to tell the truth – David Marr’s Killing for Country
Henry Reynolds Sparked a Revolution in Australian Legal History
Reconciling the Silence: Marching for the Truth on Anzac Day
Advertisement:
